Old Tacoma City Hall

Posted: 08.04.2021 | Updated: 02.12.2025

The Old City Hall was once the thriving seat of government in Tacoma, but has remained mostly vacant since the 1950s and has remained mostly vacant since then. As of right now, this iconic landmark of the Pacific Northwest is in the process of renewal and renovation.

This renovation had gone through months of development and delays, majorly due to the COVID-19 pandemic but construction constraints pushed the delay even further. It is currently set to reopen in February of 2025, with its first phase of renewal including restaurants, retail, and an office space.

Of course, any ghost enthusiast could tell you that renovations, especially with an older building, tend to stir the ghostly pot. The Old City Hall in Tacoma is no exception.

Is Old Tacoma City Hall The Most Haunted Place In Tacoma?

The Old Tacoma City Hall is haunted by a spirit prankster named Gus. Nobody knows who he really was, but they suspect that he may have been a criminal held in the building’s old city jail judging by his apparent disdain for authorities.

Gus likes to turn lights on and off, toss things around at random, and lock employees out of their offices. He’s led quite a few security guards and police officers on a wild goose chase, believing they were after an intruder. Little did they know that it was just the ghost of Gus!

Is Old Tacoma City Hall one of the most haunted places in Tacoma? You’ll have to continue reading to find out. In the mean time, why not book a tour with Seattle Terrors? Embark on one of the most wicked and unforgettable Seattle ghost tours you’ll ever experience.

Early History

In the 19th century, Tacoma was a thriving but quaint seaport at the western end of the Northern Pacific Railroad. The opportunity for growth brought many entrepreneurs from the Midwest and East Coast, who brought their fancy tastes along with them.

The Old Tacoma City Hall is an example of that fancy taste. Built in 1893, the building is an example of the Italian Renaissance architectural style. The City Hall is complete with tall windows, a red brick facade, and ornate Italianesque designs. It even has a clock tower with a set of four bells.

The bells were made by the McShane Bell Foundry in Baltimore, the same company that made the historic Liberty Bell. The bricks are said to have been part of a ship ballast. The Old City Hall in Tacoma cost over $250,000 to build, equivalent to about $7.4 million today.

From 1893 to 1957, the Old Tacoma City Hall served as the center of the Tacoma city government. It held the city jail, law offices, Tacoma Public Library, and the headquarters for many of the city’s governing officers.

Abandonment and Decline

Unfortunately, the Tacoma City Hall never got the care it needed. Regular maintenance was neglected, and the building started falling apart. It became hazardous to work in the building. Finally, in 1957, the city government of Tacoma vacated the building. They went to a much more modern location which they shared with the government of Pierce County. The Old Tacoma City Hall was left vacant.

The building went unnoticed by the city, serving as a relic of a time long gone. It narrowly dodged being torn down in the 1970s but was saved by the women of the Delphinium Garden Club. It made it onto the National Registry of Historic Places in 1974. The building saw some use from the Garden Club, as well as other tenants, but it remained mostly vacant.

Finally, local businesses raised enough money to revitalize the building in the 1980s. A few boutiques and tenants were able to move in. The Tacoma Bar and Grill moved into the first floor. Things were finally looking up.

At its high point in the 1990s, about 40 tenants had set up shop in the Old City Hall. Yet, routine maintenance was neglected, and the building was once again falling into disrepair.

Restoration

During the 2000s, the Old Tacoma City Hall was bought out by the Stratford Company. They had plans to turn the building into luxury condominiums. They evacuated the tenants by terminating their leases. Then the financial crisis of 2008 came along, and the Stratford Company was left high and dry.

Add to the fact that a burst water pipe inundated the building with over 30,000 gallons of water that same year, causing mold and mildew to thrive in the damp, dark environment. The Old City Hall was beginning to look like a lost cause.

Councilman David Boe to the rescue! With his office just across the street from the Old City Hall, David saw everything take place. Tired of standing by, he sprung into action, subsequently getting the media involved. In a series of legal moves, he forced the Stratford Company to either fix the building or get foreclosed on. They did the necessary renovations and sold the Old Tacoma City Hall for $3.5 million.

Today, the Old City Hall is still pretty empty, but that’s going to change soon. SURGE Tacoma occupies the building, and they have plans to once again turn it into a multi-use building. They’re set on attracting several businesses and companies to rent out space, as well as setting aside a few spaces for residential use.

This renovation, after many delays, is finally expected to finish early in 2025. Many wait eagerly for this historic landmark to thrive yet again.

Suicide of Edward Hatherton

The Old Tacoma City Hall was designed and built by a local architecture firm called Hatherton and McIntosh. Edward Hatherton, who assumed the role of the lead architect, was previously the City Architect of San Francisco.

He later left his post and moved to Tacoma, where he met Australian architect Colin McIntosh. Together they founded their own practice and designed several buildings in and around Tacoma.

In 1896, just three years after the completion of the Tacoma City Hall, Hatherton went missing. Considering that the city’s financial situation had cost him some serious losses, many speculated that he had committed suicide. This was confirmed when his body was found a week later.

Phantom Pranksters of Old Tacoma City Hall

The Old City Hall has had quite a long history. The city’s most influential bigwigs, as well as its worst criminals, have passed through the building. Over the years, the tenants of the Old Tacoma City Hall have encountered some strange paranormal phenomena. Most notably, the antics of a ghostly prankster known by the name “Gus.”

Nobody knows who Gus is, as there aren’t any historical records that point to a man of that name. But judging by the spirit’s lack of respect for authority, many believe he may be the ghost of a petty criminal who was held in the city jail.

Gus has a love for playing pranks on the building’s inhabitants, especially the security guards and local police. He’s known to toss objects in the air at random, turn lights on and off, and make weird movements in suspicious locations.

This is all to get a rise out of local authorities, who believe the ruckus to be a trespasser. Security guards have chased his shadow down the halls, only to arrive at a dead end. Police have been called to the building multiple times on account of his antics, only to find nobody there.

Other Paranormal Activity

The ghosts of the former Tacoma government officials also haunt the Old City Hall. Their shadows are often seen moving around the old Chamber of Commerce. Many former tenants have stories of apparitions rushing through the halls of the building as if they had some sort of important work to do.

One ghost in particular has been heard coughing, which has startled many security guards who believed they were alone in the building.

Some even say that a mysterious ghost haunts the clock tower. They’re known to randomly ring the bell every so often, usually at night when the building is empty.

Haunted Seattle (and Haunted Tacoma)

Seattle, Tacoma, and the greater Puget Sound area are some of America’s last jewels of natural beauty. The long history of Indigenous culture along with Western exploration has left quite a legacy in the region. In other words, the area is a major hotspot for ghosts!

Pay a visit to Martha Washington Park. This patch of greenery on the western coast of Lake Washington was once the home of a terrifying girls’ school, where stories of abuse and neglect were common. The ghosts of the young students often comfort troubled teen girls who pass through the park, while harassing bullies and abusers.

This is just one of many spooky spots, check out the top ten most haunted spots in Seattle for more things to do and see while you’re in the city!

Looking for a haunted hotel in Seattle to stay at? Look no further than the most haunted hotels in Seattle!

Book with Seattle Terrors for an unforgettable ghost tour in Seattle. Follow our blog, Facebook, TikTok, and Instagram for more spooky places!

Sources:

• https://www.thenewstribune.com/news/business/article295634989.html
• https://www.travelchannel.com/interests/haunted/articles/ghosts-in-tacoma-washington
• https://www.oldcityhalltacoma.com/history
• https://tacomahistory.live/2018/03/20/home-grown-obstructionists/
• https://www.oldcityhalltacoma.com/
• https://pcad.lib.washington.edu/person/6754/
• https://www.southsoundtalk.com/2016/10/12/five-haunted-tales-of-the-city-of-destiny/
• https://www.hauntedplaces.org/item/old-tacoma-city-hall/
• https://www.wahauntedhouses.com/real-haunt/old-tacoma-hall.html